Comedy Cellar is the room that made the New York showcase famous — a low-ceilinged MacDougal Street basement where five comics do fifteen minutes each and the announced lineup is regularly upstaged by whoever walks in off tour. Midweek is the sweet spot: the cover drops, the tourists thin out and the comics test rougher material. Lineups only post a few days out, which is exactly why regulars keep coming back rather than picking a night by the poster.
What to expect
Tight table seating in a basement room with a two-item minimum, a host and about five comics doing short sets. Sets are worked-out material rather than finished hours, and unannounced guests are common enough that regulars plan around them. Shows run roughly 90 minutes and the room turns over quickly between them.
Good to know
- The Cellar is at 117 MacDougal Street; A/B/C/D/E/F/M to W 4th St is a two-minute walk
- Two-item food, drink or bottled-water minimum per person on top of the ticket
- Midweek shows are cheaper and less crowded than weekends
- Village Underground around the corner runs its own separate showcases the same nights
- Lineups are posted only a few days ahead — drop-ins are the whole point
- Reservations are strongly recommended; the room is small and sells out
Planning Sep 3–4, 2026 in NYC?
This list keeps changing as events are verified. We'll send you the final version the Thursday before — and you can unsubscribe right after if that's all you need.
Common questions
Can I see the lineup before booking?
Only a few days ahead. The Cellar posts lineups late because touring headliners drop in without notice.
What is the two-item minimum?
Every guest must order two items — food, drink or even bottled water — in addition to the ticket price.
What's the difference between the Cellar and Village Underground?
They're separate rooms a few doors apart on MacDougal, each running its own showcases with their own lineups on the same nights.
More comedy that weekend
Also in Manhattan
