The premise is genuinely one of the year's best: a shepherd reads murder mysteries aloud to his sheep every night, never realising they understand every word — and when he turns up dead, the flock decides they know exactly how to solve it. Screening it free in a South Shore park, on the water at Prince's Bay, is the sort of programming that makes the Staten Island summer calendar quietly better than its reputation. Bring a blanket and get there before dark.
What to expect
The screen goes up near the Bayview Avenue side of the park, which sits on Raritan Bay with the shoreline a short walk away. Families arrive early with blankets and folding chairs to claim space on the grass. Nothing is sold on site, so bring your own snacks and drinks.
Good to know
- Free with no ticket or registration required
- The Staten Island Railway to Prince's Bay is the closest transit stop
- Bring a blanket or low chair — there is no seating
- Glass bottles and alcoholic beverages are prohibited
- Screenings begin at dusk and are canceled for heavy rain
Get Saturday planned every Thursday
One email a week — the best of the NYC weekend board. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Common questions
Is the screening free?
Yes — Movies Under the Stars is free and open to the public.
How do I get to Lemon Creek Park?
Take the Staten Island Railway to Prince's Bay; the park entrance is at Bayview Avenue and Johnston Terrace.
What is the film about?
A flock of sheep sets out to solve the murder of the shepherd who read them mysteries every night.





